Do You Have to Pay the Buyer’s Agent Commission When You Sell in California Now?

Quick Answer: No, you are not required to pay the buyer’s agent commission when you sell in California. Since the rule changes in 2024, that payment is a negotiation point, not an automatic cost. Most of the time the buyer’s agent asks for it inside the offer, and you decide whether to accept, counter or decline as part of the deal. Refusing outright is allowed, but it shrinks your buyer pool, so most sellers treat it as a term to negotiate rather than a line to delete.

This is the question I get most from sellers who last sold a home ten or twenty years ago. Back then the listing agreement set one total commission, the listing broker split it with whoever brought the buyer, and nobody thought about it again. That system is gone. The replacement is more flexible and a little more confusing.

Here is how it actually works today for a Huntington Beach seller, from the listing agreement through the offer, the net sheet and the closing statement. I will give you my honest take on what to expect and where sellers go wrong.

What Changed With the Buyer’s Agent Commission

The industry settlement that took effect in the second half of 2024 changed two things that matter to you as a seller. First, offers of compensation to a buyer’s agent can no longer be posted on the MLS. Second, buyers now sign a written agreement with their own agent before touring homes, and that agreement spells out what the buyer’s agent will be paid and by whom.

What did not change is just as important. Commissions were always negotiable, and they still are. Sellers can still choose to pay some or all of a buyer’s agent fee as a way to attract offers. Buyers can still ask the seller to cover it. The difference is that the request now has to happen inside the offer, in writing, deal by deal. The National Association of Realtors keeps a plain summary of the new rules on its settlement facts page if you want the official version.

Here is the before and after in one table:

TopicBefore the changeNow
Who sets the buyer’s agent feeListing broker, offered through the MLSBuyer and their agent, in a written buyer agreement
Where the seller sees itBaked into the listing agreement totalAs a request inside the buyer’s offer
Is it requiredExpected by customNo, negotiated per offer
Can the seller say noRarely in practiceYes, with consequences for the buyer pool

How the Request Shows Up in the Offer

When a buyer writes on your home today, their agent usually attaches a request that you, the seller, pay a stated amount toward the buyer’s broker. It sits with the purchase agreement as its own line or form. The amount is written as a percentage of the price or as a flat figure. You respond to it the same way you respond to the price, the closing date or a request for credits.

Three things to know about that request:

  1. It is part of the offer, not separate from it. A buyer offering a higher price while asking you to cover their agent is making a different offer than a buyer offering a lower price and paying their own agent. Compare the net, not the headline.
  2. You can counter it. You can accept the request, offer less, or decline it. Most of my sellers counter it alongside the price, so the whole package moves together.
  3. Some buyers pay their own agent on purpose. Investor buyers in particular sometimes cover their own agent to make a lower offer more attractive. It is a way to sweeten the deal without raising the price.

Your listing agreement is where this starts. When you sign it, you agree on what you will pay your own listing broker. You should also talk through, before you list, how you want to handle buyer’s agent requests when they arrive. I covered the rest of that document in my post on what to know before you sign a listing agreement in California.

What Sellers Should Expect to Be Asked For

Here is the practical, words-only version. Requests for buyer’s agent compensation in our area tend to fall in a range of roughly two to three percent of the purchase price. In competitive situations, where several buyers want the same house, the requests drift toward the low end or disappear. On a home that has been sitting, they drift toward the high end. Most sellers should expect a request somewhere in the middle of that range and plan for it in the net sheet.

That range is a description of what I see, not a rule. Every buyer agreement is different. A buyer whose agreement calls for a smaller fee will ask you for less. A buyer whose agreement calls for a larger fee may ask you for the full amount or make up the gap themselves. Your job is to evaluate each request as part of the offer it comes with.

How the Buyer’s Agent Fee Changes Your Net Sheet

This is where the decision becomes real. A seller net sheet lists the price, then subtracts the listing fee, any buyer’s agent payment you agreed to, escrow and title charges, prorated taxes, any credits and the loan payoff. What is left is what you walk away with.

Two offers can look very different on the first page and almost identical at the bottom:

Offer AOffer B
Higher priceLower price
Asks you to pay the buyer’s agentBuyer pays their own agent
Requests a closing cost creditNo credits requested
Net after costs: roughly the sameNet after costs: roughly the same

When the nets are close, I look at everything else: financing strength, contingency periods, closing timeline and the buyer’s flexibility. When the nets are far apart, the headline price was hiding the difference. I walk through the full sheet in my post on understanding seller net sheets and what you actually walk away with, and I run one for every offer a client receives.

One more point for sellers with a mortgage. Whatever you agree to pay the buyer’s agent comes out of your proceeds at closing, through escrow. You do not write a check and you do not pay it if the sale falls through.

Why Refusing Outright Can Shrink Your Buyer Pool

Sellers sometimes tell me they will not pay a buyer’s agent under any circumstances. That is their right. I just want them to understand the trade.

Most buyers in Huntington Beach, especially first-time buyers, are stretching to make the purchase work. Their down payment and closing costs are already spoken for. If they also have to pay their own agent out of pocket, some of them cannot write on your home at all. Others will write, but at a lower price to make room for the fee. Either way, your pool of possible buyers gets smaller, and a smaller pool means less competition and usually a lower final number.

There is also a quieter effect. Buyer’s agents know which listings are open to covering their fee and which are not. A listing that refuses on principle gets shown less, not because agents are punishing you, but because their buyers cannot afford the house with the fee added. Consequently, the sellers who do best are the ones who keep the request on the table as a negotiating chip instead of taking it off before the offers arrive.

The exception is a true multiple offer situation. When four buyers want the same home near Central Park or in the Harbour, you have the leverage to counter every request down or out. Even then, I would rather counter it than refuse it, because the counter keeps the buyer engaged.

What I Tell Sellers About Paying the Buyer’s Agent

Plan for a request, evaluate it as part of the whole offer, and negotiate it the way you would negotiate price. Do not pay it reflexively and do not refuse it reflexively. The only number that matters is your net at closing, and the best way to protect that number is to keep as many qualified buyers in the room as possible. Paying a buyer’s agent fee on a strong offer is often cheaper than losing that buyer and taking a weaker one.

Key Takeaways

  • California sellers are not required to pay the buyer’s agent commission; it is negotiated offer by offer.
  • Since the 2024 rule changes, the request arrives inside the buyer’s offer rather than through the MLS.
  • Requests in our area tend to run roughly two to three percent, lower in competitive situations, with most sellers seeing something in the middle.
  • Compare offers on the net sheet, not the headline price, since a higher price with a fee request can net the same as a lower price without one.
  • Some investor buyers pay their own agent to make a lower offer more attractive.
  • Refusing outright shrinks your buyer pool; countering keeps buyers engaged.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a seller legally required to pay the buyer’s agent in California?

No. There is no law requiring it. Whether you pay any part of the buyer’s agent fee is negotiated in each offer, and you can accept, counter or decline the request.

Where does the buyer’s agent commission request appear?

It comes with the buyer’s written offer, as its own line or attached form, stating the amount the buyer is asking you to pay toward their broker. You respond to it along with price and the other terms.

How much do buyers usually ask a seller to pay?

In our area, requests tend to fall in a range of roughly two to three percent of the price, lower when there is competition for the home. Most sellers should expect a request in the middle of that range.

Can I refuse to pay any buyer’s agent fee?

Yes. Just understand that many buyers cannot absorb the fee themselves, so a flat refusal reduces the number of buyers who can write on your home and can lower your final price.

Does paying the buyer’s agent come out of my pocket before closing?

No. Any amount you agree to is paid through escrow from your sale proceeds at closing. If the sale does not close, nothing is paid.

Do investors ever pay their own agent?

Yes. Some investor buyers cover their own agent’s fee to make a lower priced offer more appealing to the seller. Evaluate it on the net, like any other offer.

Next Step

If you are planning to sell in Huntington Beach and want to know how buyer’s agent requests will affect your bottom line, send me your address and your rough timeline. I will build a net sheet that shows your proceeds with and without a buyer’s agent payment, so you can decide with real numbers in front of you.

Google gets you 90% of the way there. I get you the other 10%.

Message me. You get me, not a team.

Jennifer Thomas and Ian Wilfert are Huntington Beach real estate partners at Seven Gables Real Estate, serving buyers and sellers across Huntington Beach and Orange County. Jennifer Thomas is a Huntington Beach real estate broker with 40 years of experience, over 1,100 closed transactions, and a reputation as one of Orange County’s most trusted listing agents and senior relocation specialists. Ian Wilfert specializes in first time home buyers, guiding clients through every step of the buying process in Huntington Beach and surrounding Orange County communities. Together Jennifer and Ian bring decades of established market knowledge and first time buyer expertise to every client they serve in Huntington Beach and Orange County. For the fastest response, contact Ian directly at 714-887-9560 or ianw@sevengables.com. Jennifer can also be reached at Jennifer@JenniferThomas.com or 714-415-5052. Visit ianwilfert.com. Jennifer Thomas DRE 00931959 | Ian Wilfert DRE 02096787.

I’m Jennifer

Consistent TOP Producer, Trustworthy, Knowledgeable, Experienced, dedicated, hard-working, enthusiastic, efficient & nice to work With! ” Jennifer goes beyond expectations”

Let’s connect